The BBC’s anti-Israel bias, overt and implicit

Biased BBC

Biased BBC

Last night I received the email below via the ICAN (International Citizens Action Network) email list run by Stuart Palmer who also blogs at Haifa Diarist.  It is only a short email, but one doesn’t need many words to express a powerful idea or to portray outrageous media bias.

The attack mentioned in the message is the one that I posted about that took place on the Egyptian border yesterday morning.

Here is the message. (emphases are mine):

Following the terror attack today on the Egyptian border, one of our members phoned the BBC complaints line 03700 100222.

Having then pressed number 1 followed by number 3. She managed to speak to a real human being, to whom the complaint was made that the BBC is not reporting the attacks across the Gaza border, nor the infiltration from Egypt into Israel and the killing of a worker.

It was pointed out that the BBC will only report these incidents, once Israel retaliates. The man who received the complaint replied,  “So the the BBC is biased against reporting the news from Israel?” He got the point!

The comments and complaint are now going to go to the special notice board, where editors will see them. http://www.complaintsboard.com/new_complaint/

We should be bombarding the BBC with such comments on a daily basis. It only takes a couple of minutes of our time.

I recommend that we all make a note of the link to the complaints notice board for future use. It’s absolutely certain that we’ll be needing it again and again

Obviously it’s hard to know whether the BBC was galvanised into reporting on the attack in the wake of that pointed phone call, or whether it was Israel’s response, or simply a reporter finally paying attention to the news.  However, although the report itself is fairly neutral (especially by BBC standards) it is exceedingly irritating that the BBC uses  the “he says she says” type of reporting, which implies in its sub-text the “Israelis only said so”, implying that something else might have really happened, i.e. it is a clash of narratives rather than neutrally reported events.  For example, the opening sentences of the BBC report:

An Israeli civilian and three militants have been killed during an attack near the southern border with Egypt, Israeli military officials have said.

They said gunmen had attacked a convoy of construction workers building a security fence along the vast border along the Sinai desert.

Two workers were injured and one later died of his wounds, Israeli media said.

“They said” is a very insidious way of planting in the mind of the reader the idea that perhaps Israel is just making it all up.  After all the report would have read perfectly coherently without the “said” words.

If you look through other articles about Israel and the Palestinians on the BBC’s Middle East page, you will find many similar examples of slanted sub-text. Just read “Palestinians shot dead in West Bank” (Haaretz report for comparison) or “Palestinian footballer Sarsak ends hunger strike” which conveniently hides that the vaunted footballer is in fact an active member of the military wing of the Palestinian Islamic Jihad (see CifWatch’s article).

Just make a note of the BBC complaints page and use it when necessary!

This entry was posted in Media and journalism and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to The BBC’s anti-Israel bias, overt and implicit

  1. Matt, London says:

    Hi there, just came across your blog via CiFWatch. I’ll be sure to check back. Thank you!

    • anneinpt says:

      Hello Matt, thank you for your comment and welcome to my blog. I’ve seen your comments on CiFWatch too and I’m very glad you’ve found my blog. I hope to see your around here again very soon!

  2. annediamond1@aol.com says:

    Most Jews in the UK have that view, it does get reported many have also looked at the political situation. I left one political party as I could not agree how it was dealing with Israel, and why there were boycotts in Universities as well as trades……
    The BBC is not showing the sides of the argument in a fair and positive way., forward for all sides. Yet Jews in the UK I believe only want peace on all sides to have the middle east share in the beauty and understand how to live along side all….

    • anneinpt says:

      You’ve nailed the point exactly Anne. Jews everywhere, not just in England, would like to see peace on both sides, but with media like the BBC and Guardian actively promoting only one side, it makes peace much harder to attain because they give moral support to the terrorists.

Add your comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s