The tragic fate of Egypt’s Christians

Coptic Church burned in Egypt

One of the most tragic outcomes of the upheaval in Egypt is the dire fate of its Christian population.  Raymond Ibrahim of the Gatestone Institute noted:

Under Morsi’s one year of rule, many more Christians were attacked, arrested, and imprisoned for “blasphemy” than under Mubarak’s thirty years.

This is not to say that all was perfect under Mubarak’s regime. Far from it.  But their situation worsened dramatically under the Muslim Brotherhood. An article in the Times of Israel describes the tragic fate of the Copts in Egypt:

Since the violent crackdown in Egypt began on Monday, August 12th, nearly 20 Coptic Christian churches and several Coptic owned properties in Egypt were torched to the ground by supporters of the Muslim Brotherhood. Leaked reports over the past weeks have stated that the Muslim Brotherhood tried to assassinate the Coptic Patriarch, Pope Tawadros II on several occasions. Since the overthrow of the democratically elected Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi, his supporters, who are described as “anti-coup” and “pro-democracy,” have stated clearly that Coptic Christians are no longer safe in Egypt.

Copts are the largest indigenous Christian minority in the Middle East and North Africa, comprising an estimated 10 percent of Egypt’s total population. Since Egypt’s military coup of 1952, Copts have been faced with a variety of human rights violations including institutionalized discrimination, marginalization from civic society, and being the victim of acts of violence.

Following the euphoria of the 2011 revolution, Coptic Christians were filled with hope. The overthrow of Egypt’s military dictator, Hosni Mubarak was seen as opening a new chapter in the life of all Egyptians which proved to be true, but in a different way than they had expected. In 2011, the number of attacks on Copts rose dramatically. Coptic homes, shops, businesses, fields and livestock were plundered and Coptic individuals were brutally killed. By the end of 2011, nearly 93,000 Coptic Christians had fled Egypt as refugees.

Two thousand and twelve was no less a violent year. … In a deal to prevent further violent attacks on Christians, members of Salfist party, Alnour and the Muslim Brotherhood, forced as many as 100 Coptic Christian families to leave their homes in the Village of Dahshour. At least 16 homes of Christians were pillaged, some were torched, and a church was damaged during the violence. Christian families living in the Sinai Peninsula also fled their homes fearing the rise of Islamic groups. On April 20th, 2013, Dennis Ross of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy was quoted in Al-Ahram Weekly saying that, no fewer than 100,000 Copts had left Egypt since the Muslim Brotherhood came to power,” a fact confirmed by a number of human rights groups.

In 2013, all hell broke loose…

[…]

A message to the church of Egypt, from an Egyptian Muslim: I tell the church — by Allah, and again, by Allah — if you conspire and unite with the remnants [opposition] to bring Morsi down, that will be another matter…. our red line is the legitimacy of Dr. Muhammad Morsi. Whoever splashes water on it, we will splash blood on him.”

[…]

For months Egypt’s Coptic Christens listened to a promise of extermination, accompanied by weekly violent attacks. No attempt was made by anyone including the Egyptian military, the UN or the US government to protect and reassure the Copts. The Copts have faced their fate alone, as they always have.  Attacks on churches, shootings of priests in broad daylight, and burning of Coptic owned properties is common daily news

[…]

Earlier this week, when the army and police started their crackdown against Morsi’s supporters, the Islamists reacted by striking back against the army and by attacking Copts, as promised. In less than 24 hours an estimated 20 Coptic churches, houses and community buildings were torched all over Egypt. The Egyptian military is cleaning house and the Copts are paying a heavy price.

Here the author reminds us, in a similar manner to former President Hosni Mubarak’s warning that the West misreads the Islamists and projects Western characteristics of an oppressed religious minority onto a murderous cult:

Please do not forget for a minute that the ruthless pro-Morsi Muslim Brotherhood Islamists are the ones described in western media as “pro-democracy” and “anti-coup”, as if they are a liberal, modern, and highly educated group of people engaged in a peaceful process of civil disagreement and advancement. The Middle East has a much different cultural framework than the West and it is idiotic to apply Western notions of modern politics and democracy to the Middle East. As I write this, the Muslim Brotherhood’s “pro-democracy” protestors are promising martyrdom for those who die for Morsi and scapegoating Coptic Christians through destruction and murder. What part of the Muslim Brotherhood’s undemocratic, delusional ideology is hard for the West to understand? How can Western governments and the media  be sympathetic and supportive of them?

And if all this sounds rather familiar and similar to the Jewish experience both in Europe and the Muslim world, it is because there are indeed many similarities:

There once lived a great Jewish community in Egypt that has been lost forever. Just as 80,000 Egyptian Jews were abused and fled, today Coptic Christians are facing similar religious persecution, yet they don’t have any other home country to turn to. Today, the world is preoccupied with the current political turmoil in Egypt, while ignoring the ongoing catastrophe faced by an indigenous Middle Eastern Coptic Christians. One of the churches burned by Muslim Brotherhood supporters, was the Prince Tadros Church in Al Minya – a 4th century church which contained ancient manuscripts on Orthodox theology. Is the West ready to accept such a loss? Are power and money more important than human life and history?

When the world ignores or minimizes Jewish suffering we just sigh and accept that this is what the gentiles do.  Of course we try and fight back but we know that anti-Semitism is part and parcel of the Jewish experience.

But where is the world’s outrage at what is being done to the Christians across the Middle East? Has the West become completely blinded by its smug self-righteous liberalism?

This entry was posted in Israel news and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to The tragic fate of Egypt’s Christians

  1. roxymuzak says:

    The Jews saw the hieroglyphics on the wall in Egypt a long time ago and fled, wise move. Amazing to think that Egypt, home of Jews for thirty-two centuries, is now no more. I read once that Egypt’s first Finance Minister, after they gained independence in the 1920s, was a Jew. You’d have a better chance of Hamas opening a Synagogue in Gaza than that happening now. Christianity, a breakaway Jewish sect, predates Islam by centuries in Egypt. Now they face the same choice as their elder brothers and sisters in God. Ultimately, it is Egypt that will pay the price. Civilisations that embrace the Judeo-Christian culture flourish. Embrace Islam and you’ll find yourself in proximity to people who think the invention of the wheel was a bit on the liberal side.

  2. anneinpt says:

    This is one case where the Jews were luckier than the Christians. As is pointed out in the article, where can the Christians flee to? The Jews of Egypt could flee to Israel. The Christians have no other country that will take them in. Christian charity evidently has its limits, especially when confronted with Muslim violence.

  3. roxymuzak says:

    The Christains can always appeal to Israel to open their doors, until the death cult, anti life plague of radical Islam has passed. The battle against radical Islam, apreciating that Israel is in the front line, is a cause for grave concern for civisilation itself, not just the Jews. In Europe, in WW2, civilisation stood up against the Nazis. It must do the same against Islam and its enablers on European left, the latter being the biggest threat.

    • anneinpt says:

      The Copts could appeal to Israel, and knowing Israel’s humanitarianism they would most likely open their doors.

      However – a big however – the enemy of my enemy is not necessarly my friend, certainly not in the Middle East. The Copts are no friends of Israel and they probably wouldn’t dream of asking those dastardly Zionists for help. Read this article in the Voice of the Copts to understand what is happening. The key paragraph:

      Islamic bigotry and prejudice against Jews in Egypt predates the Jewish State of Israel. Islam’s discriminatory teachings have dominated Egypt’s culture for centuries and have been passed down through generations, infecting Muslims and Christians alike. Public school textbooks saturate Muslim and non-Muslim children in their formative years with messages of hate toward Israel and Jews. Today Christian Copts are awash in the culture of Islam like fish in water and many grossly err in relation to Christ’s teachings on the issue of Jews and Coptic biblical history and heritage.

      Bombarded daily with Egypt’s state regulated media dominated by biased Islamic viewpoints, forced to listen to loud speakers blasting Friday prayers from mosques preaching hatred of Jews and Christians, the Coptic Christians and their clergy are an indoctrinated population.

      This is a sad reality that is terribly inexcusable especially as Coptic religious leaders have conceded this point to Muslims in order to appease them and perhaps make Coptic life less dangerous which has been miserably unsuccessful. Regarding the State of Israel, Copts love the holy land and the Christian sites located there yet, at the same time, view with skepticism the Jewish population.

      5. How do Coptic Christians view “Christian Zionists” who support Israel as a fulfillment of Bible prophecy?

      Coptic Christians are not adherents of the Christian Zionist movement and never speak of supporting Israel in ways that fulfill biblical prophecy — …

      It is very worrying what will happen to the Copts because I don’t see the rest of the Christian world rushing to their aid, or even protesting loudly.

      Of course if it was the Jews who were doing the oppressing we’d have had huge demos in Trafalgar Square, furious editorials in the NYT and the Guardian, blaring headlines in the BBC and countless resolutions in the UN.

  4. Pingback: The anti-Israel Grinch who stole Christmas | Anne's Opinions

Comments are closed.