Malachi Moshe Rosenfeld HY’D succumbs to his wounds after drive-by shooting

Malachi Moshe Rosenfeld HY’D

Malachi Moshe Rosenfeld HY’D, the most seriously injured of the four young men in Monday night’s drive-by shooting near Shilo, died earlier today from the wounds he suffered during the terror attack:

Malachi Moshe Rosenfeld, 25, who was seriously wounded at a drive-by shooting attack near Shilo on Monday night, succumbed to his wounds at the Shaare Zedek Medical Center in Jerusalem on Tuesday, his family said.

Ynet’s report adds more details about the attack and the IDF response:

Initial investigation found that two terrorists ambushed Israeli vehicles in a car with Palestinian plates on the Alon road, a side road, but relatively well-lit, near the settlement Shilo. Shortly before 11 pm, the terrorists noticed an Israeli vehicle traveling their way, and opened fire at the front of the car from short-range. At least 15 9 mm bullets hit the Israeli car.

The terrorists continued firing at the vehicle even after the driver made a sharp turn towards the settlement Migdalim. After driving for 200 meters more, the Israeli vehicle stopped and its passengers called for help.

The terrorists managed to flee the scene in their car. Palestinians have complete freedom of movement on this road, as they do on all other main roads in the West Bank – this is not expected to change following the attack.

The IDF decided on Tuesday to reinforce its presence in the West Bank with an additional infantry battalion from the Nahal Brigade as a result of the recent spike in terror attacks in the area. The battalion will deal with defensive operations.

A high ranking official in the IDF said, “There is no collective punishment to the Palestinian population, and the steps that have been taken are a direct result of the current situation assessment and intelligence picture.”

“The moment we get our hands on the perpetrators of the recent attacks we believe that the attacks will stop,” he added. “The coordination with the Palestinian security forces continues as do the conversations with the settlers.”

He also stressed that Israel was “far from what happened in the second intifada notwithstanding recent attacks. The recent attacks are a local group, and there is no connection between the attacks. There is no terror infrastructure behind the attacks.”

More importantly, here is more about Malachi Rosenfeld’s short life:

Rosenfeld, the son of popular Israeli clarinetist Eliezer Rosenfeld, was a graduate of the Machon Lev technological yeshiva in Jerusalem, and was studying at the Hebrew University.

To personalise this somewhat, Eliezer Rosenfeld and his band played at our daughter’s wedding a couple of years ago, and our son-in-law, the bridegroom at that wedding, is also a student at the same Machon Lev technological yeshiva.

To humanise the victims still further, the Muqata posted a simple picture of a happy local basketball team which has been shattered by the terror attack:

The fact that the Rosenfeld’s have already lost another son makes this tragedy even harder to bear. The Ynet article continues:

The two parents said that since they lost Malachi’s older brother, an IAF pilot who died on a trip to Tze’elim Stream in the Judean Desert in 2002, “Malachi took the big brother role upon himself. He has a lot of love to the younger children in the family.”

After learning of his son’s passing, Eliezer told Ynet that Malachi “was a exceptional child, very clever, rationalist, genius and sensitive… he was always victorious and was the king of the world. Yesterday he only went to play basketball, came back to the settlement and was murdered in cold blood. This is a terrible tragedy.”

Rosenfeld’s cousin Ariel Bar Asher said that “Malachi was very much like his brother who died, both externally and internally. He had a good soul, friendly, pleasant, a genius and brilliant… he took charge of the family after his brother was killed. He was about to finish his bachelor’s degree in a month.”

The family consented to a request from the National Transplant Center to donate Malachi’s cornea. “This is a big mitzvah,” his father said.

Malachi’s wounded team-mates relate the whole incident and their feelings:

Yair Hoffer, who was lightly wounded in the shooting, recounted the attack on Tuesday morning. “When we returned from the basketball game, a vehicle was slowly driving in front of us, and suddenly we heard the shots and realized we were being shot at,” he said.

“Thank God, we were a few meters away from the junction. If I had been driving, we might have been closer to the junction and it would have been easier for them to aim. I didn’t see how many people were there. I guess they shot about a magazine. When they were done they didn’t drive very fast, they drove slowly, I think they were debating whether to leave the vehicle. I crawled outside through the window.

“When the shots start you just curl up and try to protect your head. I will never forget the feeling, it’s just helplessness. When someone decides to try to take your life, and you didn’t do anything to him. Decided to try taking your life because he realized you’re a Jew. And you’re helpless…

“It’s also important for me to say, they say ‘settlers’, like if it were in Tel Aviv it would be different. I’m a settler, what does that mean? I grew up in Jerusalem and I looked for a nice place with a community to raise my children.”


Hoffer’s description of the attack is horrifying and heart-breaking, yet he is right on the nail with the media’s use of the word “settlers” to belittle and delegitimize those Israelis who choose to live over the “Green Line”, that fictitious border which was only a ceasefire line.

I wish continued refuah shlema to the injured victims.

The Rosenfeld family’s courage and forbearance in the face of this tragedy is admirable and humbling. May they be comforted amongst the mourners of Zion and Jerusalem and may they know no more sorrow.

May the memory of Malachi Moshe Rosenfeld be for a blessing. יהי זכרו ברוך. ברוך דיין אמת.

This entry was posted in Terrorism and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Malachi Moshe Rosenfeld HY’D succumbs to his wounds after drive-by shooting

  1. NormanF says:

    It makes my blood boil to hear that the Israeli government holds Arab freedom of movement is more important than protecting Jewish lives.

    It might as well have handed the Arabs terrorists the guns to shoot Malachi Moshe Rosenfeld and they’re shrugging and saying in not so many words, we can’t risk offending the Arabs.

    All we can do is bury and mourn our dead. Gevalt!

    • anneinpt says:

      There is a lot of anger here right now for the very reasons you cite. This has been an ongoing problem since the cursed Oslo Accords were signed.

  2. ShimonZ says:

    יהי רצון שנתעורר ונעשה צדק כל עוד שאפשרי. איזו בושה לעם ישראל! חילול ה

  3. Reality says:

    ברוך דיין האמת
    Such a terrible tragedy.So now for a few days ,various roads have been closed off to the Palestinians. Big deal.As soon as some “humanitarian”free thinker demands non collective punishment,everything will start again.Has no one asked how come the Palestinians are prepared to to do collective punishment on the entire nation of Jews and kill them wherever they are for no reason whatsoever? Sad to say,but yes we do need to think how to prevent attacks, not just to react to them afterwards.They will only stop when they see Israel acts forcefully ,and with pride.If we don’t feel proud to be Israeli,and act from a position of strength ,these attacks will continue,and grow. The “free thinking humanitarians be damned!”

  4. NormanF says:

    Giving the Arabs the freedom to kill Jews by showing them compassion and goodwill doesn’t make them reciprocate.

    What Jews consider civilized behavior is seen as weakness by the Arabs and they take advantage
    of it.

    Israelis need to wake up and realize the Middle East is not the West.

    • anneinpt says:

      Believe me, Israelis are wide awake and know very well where they are. The trouble is that our leaders think they can buy the West’s love by being conciliatory to the Arabs. Or they think that they can buy some quiet from the Arabs by the same conciliation.

      But it’s only ever a temporary fix, if that. We vote for the right every time, and yet they behave “left’. I don’t understand it, I have no explanation.

  5. Pingback: And now the bad news: the anti-Israel ICC; terrorists released in the Shalit deal return to terror | Anne's Opinions

Comments are closed.