Poland rewrites its history of the Shoah

Auschwitz, a Nazi death camp in Poland

The new Polish legislation to criminalize anyone who claims that Poland played a part in the Shoah has outraged all Jews from across the world, as well as angering genuine historians.  The fear is that Poland is attempting to whitewash its citizens’ role in the Shoah as Amanda Borschel-Dan writes in the Times of Israel:

This week Polish Prime Minister Beata Szydlo’s Cabinet approved a bill which would criminalize the use of the phrase “Polish death camps” in reference to Nazi-run extermination camps in occupied Poland. Use of the banned expression could lead to a three-year jail term if considered intentional, or a hefty fine.

“It wasn’t our mothers, nor our fathers, who are responsible for the crimes of the Holocaust, which were committed by German and Nazi criminals on occupied Polish territory,” said Justice Minister Zbignew Ziobro on Tuesday. “Our responsibility is to defend the truth and dignity of the Polish state and the Polish nation, as well as our fathers, our mothers and our grandparents.”

The legislation was originally proposed by Szydlo’s ruling Law and Justice Party (PiS) in 2013, when it was rejected. Upon rising to power in 2015, however, PiS vowed to “recalibrate many of the ways in which Poles think, talk and learn about their own history,” according to German news agency Deutsche Welle, and to instill national pride.

Astonishingly, one Polish Jewish community leader thinks this is a good idea!

The nationalistic new government’s zero tolerance for the use of “Polish death camps” was lauded this week by young Polish Jewish community leader Klaudia Klimek, head of the Krakow branch of Poland’s largest Jewish cultural organization TSKZ.

Representing Poland’s 10,000-strong active Jewish community, Klimek said TSKZ’s president Artur Hoffman has also spoken in support of the bill — at the Israeli Knesset and as a consulting member of the Polish government’s commission of minorities.

In conversation with The Times of Israel, Klimek stressed the need for historical accuracy when speaking of the Holocaust, which was, she said, an atrocity committed by the German Nazi regime on occupied land. Unlike the case in other European countries, the Polish nation never collaborated with the Nazi regime, said Klimek. There were bad Poles, as well as good Poles, during World War II.

“We cannot say as a generalization that the Poles, or Polish society were involved in the Holocaust,” said Klimek. However, “because the majority of the Holocaust happened in Poland, the Polish society is reacting, and taking care of the history.”

But it is not as simple as that, as the article continues:

But after a summer of PiS politicians playing fast and loose with history, one could wonder whether this new “Polish death camps” law is a manifestation of nationalistic Poles’ historical whitewashing.

The legislation comes a month after high-profile historical “mistakes” were made by PiS politicians surrounding well-documented massacres perpetrated by Poles.

Most prominent among them, in a mid-July interview on Polish public broadcaster TVN, Education Minister Anna Zalewska insinuated that the Jedwabne massacre of 1941, when Poles burned alive more than 300 Jews in a barn, was a matter of “opinion.”

Jews from Poland and abroad gather for commemorations marking the 75th anniversary of a massacre of Jews in Jedwabne, Poland, on July 10, 2016. (AP Photo/Michal Kosc)

Zalewska is hardly alone. As reported by Polish Newsweek, a Polish public opinion survey following Zalewska’s statements found that 33% of the population agreed with the minister that the Polish massacre of Jews at Jedwabne is an opinion, 29% were undecided and only 38% agreed with the statement that “Poles burned Jews in a barn in Jedwabne.” The highest percentage of disbelief was found among youth.

Additionally, newly elected president of the Polish state’s Institute of National Remembrance Jaroslaw Szarek, according to a JTA report, recently told a parliamentary committee that “the perpetrators of this crime were the Germans, who used in their own machine of terror a group of Poles.”

Concurrently, to the condemnation of Klimek and other Jewish officials, the Polish government issued yet another in a series of rejections to Jewish community petitions to open the door to restitution claims from Holocaust survivors.

Yad Vashem, Israel’s national Holocaust Memorial museum, prefers historically accurate terminology:

Israel’s national Holocaust memorial and museum Yad Vashem told The Times of Israel on Wednesday that, as it has since 2006, it endorses the suggested replacement terminology — “the former German Nazi Concentration and Extermination Camp.” The Israeli institution has recognized over 6,000 Poles as “Righteous Among the Nations” for rescuing Jews; some 3 million Polish Jews died in the Holocaust.

But what instigated this legislation in the first place?

In the aftermath of the Polish Cabinet approval of the new bill, Tel Aviv University History Professor Havi Dreifuss wondered at the motivation behind the legislation.

“Although there is no argument that those camps were established by the Germans, as a historian it is always worrying and disturbing to see the use of law to impose something on common knowledge,” said Dreifuss, the head of the Center for Research on the Holocaust in Poland at Yad Vashem.

Funeral of the Jews killed in the Kielce pogrom of 1946 (l) and plaque in their memory, inaugurated by Lech Walesa, in 1990.

At the same time, said Dreifuss, historians, including Polish scholars, have unearthed concrete proof of two major massacres against Jews, 1941’s Jedwabne, and the 1946 Kielce massacre, in which 42 people died. She added that contemporary research shows there were other such massacres of Jews like Jedwabne at the hands of Poles in the region of Lomza. More study is necessary to completely uncover the facts behind these atrocities.

And despite the best efforts of the Polish government, awkward facts refuse to go away, facts like the complicity of Polish citizens in the killings of Jews:

Historian Jan Tomasz Gross’s 2001 book “Neighbors” caused shockwaves in Poland and beyond with its descriptions of the “ordinary” Poles who perpetrated the 1941 Jedwabne massacre. Gross, who was awarded the Knight’s Cross of the Order of Merit in 1996, has been an object of vilification under the PiS government. In February 2016, Polish President Andrzej Duda went so far as to request a re-evaluation of Gross’s worthiness for the medal due to the scholar’s attempts to “destroy Poland’s good name,” said Duda.

Poland’s “good name” which President Duda is so concerned about, is going to be hard to rehabilitate given the eager participation of many of its citizens in massacring their Jewish neighbours. Alexander Boot, a (non-Jewish) Russian emigré living in England, writes on his blog that “It wasn’t just the Germans“:

But the job wasn’t done yet. Einsatzengruppen and the local collaborators began to round up and shoot Jews. Most of the firing squads didn’t include a single German – there was no shortage of local volunteers. By the end of the war, only a couple of hundred Lwów Jews were still alive.

Thus three times the number of Jews were killed in that one city than in the whole of occupied France, where local enthusiasm wasn’t exactly in short supply either. Why such disparity? What made Lwów so much more efficient?

Actually, it wasn’t just Lwów. Simply compare the numbers of massacred Jews relative to their overall numbers in a small sample of European countries.

Western Europe: Germany, 142,000 out of 565,000; Austria, 50,000 out of 185,000; Denmark, 60 out of 8,000; Finland, 7 out of 2,000; Italy, 7,500 out of 44,500; France, 77,000 out of 250,000.

Eastern Europe: Greece, 65,000 out of 75,000; Hungary, 550,000 out of 825,000; Latvia, 70,000 out of 91,500; Lithuania, 140,000 out of 168,000; Czechoslovakia, 78,000 out of 118,000; Poland, 3,000,000 out of 3,300,000.

A map of the distribution of Jews in Europe comparing from 1933 to 1950.

You’ll notice that a much higher percentage of Jews were killed in Eastern Europe than even in Germany, which after all initiated the Holocaust and built the death camps.

Why such disparity? I can think of only one answer: Eastern Europeans didn’t mind the Holocaust as much, and were more than willing to lend the Germans a helping hand.

Another question: why did the Nazis set up all the extermination (as opposed to concentration) camps in Poland? Auschwitz, Belzec, Chełmno, Jasenovac, Majdanek, Maly Trostenets, Sobibor and Treblinka were all there.

To some extent, it must have been a matter of logistics: most of Europe’s Jewish population lived there or thereabouts, in what used to be the Pale of Settlement.

But it couldn’t have been just logistics. After all, the Nazis didn’t mind using hundreds of trains badly needed for military freight to transport Jews from, say, France all the way to Poland. It would have been more efficient to kill them in situ.

Also in the back of the Nazis’ mind must been the issue of post-war deniability for the Germans. Had those crematorium chimneys been spewing clouds of black smoke in, say, Hamburg, it would have been hard for its denizens to claim they didn’t know.

As it was, such claims weren’t all that credible anyhow, as Daniel Goldhagen demonstrates convincingly in his instructive book Hitler’s Willing Executioners. But he also shows that the Nazis were wary of a potential backlash from the Germans had they had to watch mass murder committed on their own doorstep. No such fears in Poland.

He [Duda] also objects to the death camps being referred to as ‘Polish’. I agree that ‘German camps in Poland’ would be more accurate. But those camps wouldn’t have been in Poland if the locals had detested them.

They didn’t. At best, they shrugged their shoulders with indifferent acquiescence. At worst, tens of thousands of them took an active part in the atrocities. And those who deny these facts are the murderers’ accomplices after the fact.

Melanie Phillips thinks that Poland is unleashing its own inner demons with this legislation:

SOME YEARS AGO, when I visited Poland for the first and only time, I was astonished to be told there something I have since repeatedly heard: that the Jews were murdered in the concentration camps in Poland because they were Poles.

This is of course hideously untrue. Polish Jews were murdered in the camps because they were Jews.

It’s true that, as Yad Vashem testifies, Poland produced the greatest number of non-Jews recognized for saving Jews during the Holocaust. It’s also true that Poles were murdered in great number alongside them.

Such facts aren’t negated by the reality that Jews were also victimized by Poles. The Poles were victims of Nazism just as they were also victims of communism. They were not targeted as the Jews were for genocide.

The reason Poles deny that the Jews were victims of Nazi antisemitism is that this would reveal the Poles were victimizers, too. They murdered their Jewish compatriots because they hated Jews.

Making themselves equal in victimization to the Jews enables them to deny their own complicity in the attempt to liquidate the Jewish people. So they are coming up with preposterous and deeply offensive claims to deny Jewish victimization at Polish hands.

Strikingly, though, Poland is a great ally of Israel – which makes this a diplomatic crisis. So why is a country with such a deeply embedded anti-Jewish culture so keen on the Jewish state?

The answer is almost certainly in large part an attempt to bury Poland’s terrible past, whether out of genuine remorse or expediency – or both.

There’s also a difference between young, urban, cosmopolitan Poles, who have a genuine fascination with Jewish culture, and those in rural areas, many of whom remain rooted in a medieval form of Christianity, which still teaches that Jews murder Christian children for their blood.

There are some prominent Poles who speak frankly about Polish complicity in the Holocaust. “Of course Poles took part,” Wlodzimierz Cimoszewicz, Poland’s prime minister during the mid-1990s, told the newspaper Rzeczpospolita. He urged Poles to talk “openly and honestly” about the “tens of thousands” of “szmalcowniks” – Poles who informed on Jews or extorted their property. “Antisemitism was and remains endemic in our country,” he said.

And if you still don’t think that’s possible, just watch the exchange in the two videos below, between Israeli journalist Ronen Bergman and the Polish Prime Minister a couple of days ago, where the Polish PM now accuses the Jews of complicity in the Holocaust!:

Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu has promised to speak with the Polish PM about this – but will it be enough?


The outrageousness of Morawiecki’s bold assertions and bald lies boggle the mind. Any slightly valid point he may have had regarding the description of the death camps as “Polish” rather than “Nazi” has been lost in his morass of historical revision, bordering on Holocaust denial.

This entry was posted in Antisemitism, History, International relations and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Poland rewrites its history of the Shoah

  1. Pingback: Poland rewrites its history of the Shoah – 24/6 Magazine

  2. Reality says:

    The Poles always were and will be anti Semitic.Nothing has changed.People tell of how after the war when going back to search their cities for any relatives,Poles would shoot them.
    My niece went on a school trip to Poland about 20 years ago ,to Zamosc where my late mother in law comes from.As they walked through the streets,Polish people saw them and started cursing the group ,calling them filthy Jews,vermin etc .Plenty of times I have yheard of Jews being beaten up in Poland because they are Jews.However disgusting the Germans were,at least nowadays they teach about the holocaust and tolerance .That is missing from Polish education and culture.They want to whitewash it entirely.
    Absolutely disgraceful

  3. Jeff Polaski says:

    I must regretfully point out that following the end of the war, Russia incorporated many countries into the Soviet Union. Russia was anti-Semitic throughout the century. The countries it controlled had their histories controlled by the Kremlin’s puppets, and accuracy of the Holocaust was not permitted. The Soviets were happy to rewrite history — it is what they and their successors do.
    This is most starkly illustrated by the difference in education between West Germany (teaching truth) and East Bloc’s East Germany, where the Stasi enforced lies.
    Therefore, the children were taught, post-war, what the Russians permitted. The Russians not only permitted, but promoted disinformation, as they do today. Consider the stark difference between East German false “history” and West German history as it leaves its mark today.
    I am not surprised to see Polish people believing the lies about the atrocities their parents and grandparents committed. They were taught evil lies.
    This is not an excuse for today’s Polish behavior. It is history — the revised history that worked out very badly for Poles and other East Bloc peoples who may never understand or want to understand what really happened.
    I am Jeffrey Lewis ( Yosef Laib) Polaski, and I wear my name in honor of my grandfather who fled Biesk, Poland, so that his family would live. He changed the name from Beilpolsky to Polaski, so that he could work and feed his family in America.

    • anneinpt says:

      Jeff, thank you for that very good point you made about the Soviet disinformation and miseducation campaign. Yet it does not excuse Polish behaviour today. Today they are not under any Soviet or any other oppressor. They are their own bosses with their own government, so what is causing this sudden reversion to the “sins of their youth”?

      Thank you too for your family history. It is of vital importance to continue our nation’s chain down the generations, and you are continuing your own family’s unbroken chain. That is our revenge against those who would destroy us.

  4. leonkushner says:

    I am hyper sensitive about Poland since I heard many terrible stories about what the Poles did to us from my parents who survived the Holocaust.

    I wrote the following on my blog in the Jerusalem Post:


    Now they are out lawing shechita. Next they’ll outlaw circumcision.

    Best regards, Leon


    • anneinpt says:

      Wow, that is a very hard-hitting article Leon! Kol hakavod on writing it, on describing things as they truly are. Very well written.

      I recommend you all read it.

      • Jeff Polaski says:

        I read it. My father’s father came from Bielsk at the beginning of the last century. I learned only about 12 years ago that my father’s grandmother was in Philadelphia at mid-century. When I asked my father about it in 2006, he said only, “it was very bad there.” That’s all. My father died in 2008 and now I will never know.
        Those who came to America before the Shoah very rarely talked about it. It was as if they were ashamed about it. Leon is correct that it needs to be known by as many people as possible. I have researched Bielsk and its desecrated Jewish cemeteries, Yes, it was bad.
        Thank you both for this gift of speaking out.

Comments are closed.